Comments on: New Black Kids Video - I’m Not Gonna Teach Your Boyfriend How to Dance with You

By: Tylor S.

Tylor S. — Thu, 31 Jul 2008 03:10:32 +0000

@ Dennie C

I miss both lugnut and honey locust. Good times. They need to do a ska-disco-(for lack of better word) “indie”-(again lack of better word)-stomp version of I hate school…

By: The Straight Truth

The Straight Truth — Wed, 23 Apr 2008 05:06:57 +0000

Todd, I completely agree on my mistake. “Horrendous” was entirely too strong of a word to describe BK. Perhaps “lackluster” would have been a more fitting term.

By: Todd Grant

Todd Grant — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 18:26:49 +0000

But, I will say it is funny to assert that the singer guy was DJ’ing at old TSI 4-5 years ago, because 1) 5 years ago that place was still a shithole liquor store/lounge, and 2) 4 years ago I went there all the time and never once saw that guy behind the laptop.

By: Todd Grant

Todd Grant — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 18:24:53 +0000

Wow, I don’t much care for the band, or their music, I think “horrendous” is a little strong, no? I mean, they are clearly better than a lot of schlock out there. While I personally do not care for the music, I can clearly say that it is not motivated by any animus towards them, unlike S.T. here.

By: The Straight Truth

The Straight Truth — Mon, 21 Apr 2008 18:04:27 +0000

Apparently Jacksonville is going deaf, or is blinded by friendship or the glitz of a band actually landing a successful tour. The Black Kids may be earning some success now, but it is only for the fact of a very simplistic and catchy song, and the overhyping it’s received. Pitchfork has been known to catapult some pretty horrendous bands in the past, and Black Kids are no exception. While some of the members may be nice people, and apparently have all their buddies standing up for them here, the fact of the matter is that the rest of the music doesn’t have enough strength to pull them through for very long. The industry will chew them up and spit them out if they can’t come up with stronger and more organized material that won’t land them in the bargain bin next year. They could surprise us critics, but I honestly just don’t see it happening right now.

And regarding Brendon’s statement that they got the kids into the music they’re into now a whole whopping 4-5 years back: No, they didn’t. There were other DJs on the scene in Jacksonville before them that also helped found and build the indie exposure. Sure, they may have helped, but it was a collective effort between several people. Perhaps if you weren’t 17 at the time, you could have seen this.

By: Puppy

Puppy — Wed, 26 Mar 2008 03:51:13 +0000

Wow, they have definitely grown a lot since they left Jax. I hope they continue to grow and be successful. Cool video, too.

By: Dennie C

Dennie C — Tue, 25 Mar 2008 14:10:50 +0000

What horrible emo band??? I don’t seem to remember that I remember lots of bands from these guys though… like Cubby and The Dirty Birds, neither of which were emo, both of which were something in the range of 5 years ago … AND both really good local bands who worked hard but didn’t make it out of Jacksonville. (and that’s not even getting into the whole Lugnut and Honey Locust thing of high school times both of which were out on the road touring from what I remember)

So, they deserve everything they get and I’m glad they are the guys repping Jax… belive me it could be a whole lot worse (anyone remember Limp Bizkit?).

Anyway great video, and this song just keeps growing on me… often times I catch myself singing it to myself…

*Incidentally, I was over in London a couple of weeks ago and it was really weird to walk into a shoe store and open up some local London fanzine and read about guys you know from back home….

By: Tr-indie

Tr-indie — Tue, 25 Mar 2008 00:00:16 +0000

Actually, I have to say, having looked up and read the singer’s interview with the Guardian from last Friday, he seems like an earnest guy and even owns up to being in that terrible emo band– which not many guys who suddenly find themselves in the limelight would do, so I have to say, to a certain degree, I stand corrected.

By: zZzZzZz

zZzZzZz — Mon, 24 Mar 2008 22:58:46 +0000

i’m happy for them.
it’s not my kind of music but they are good folks.

however, and this is aimed at other comments, i don’t buy into the whole idea about music being purely born taste. i think like any taste it develops over time bent to innate leanings. what that means in the realm of opinions i don’t know. probably nothing, but i believe a few people had a point about this kind of music sort of being the status quo and not building on much and not really adding anything to music as a whole.
does that decrease it’s value or mean there’s something wrong with their success?
no, of course not.
it’s just a different branch of music.
it’s dance and it’s pop.
it’s music that seeks to entertain and give people what they want which is more stuff to listen to and dance to.
they do it well and there’s nothing wrong with that.
you just have to learn to separate that kind of music from music built on … well i guess art or progression or idea expression… whatever all that means. one form is in no way superior to the other… it’s just a different area and approach. you can’t take this type of stuff too seriously or you’ll hemorrhage.

anyway…
im not into the video but it fits and all.

and now i’m wondering why i commented.
i guess i like to debate.

By: Chad

Chad — Mon, 24 Mar 2008 14:04:22 +0000

*of - not out